Discover Blue Moon Ice Cream | The Midwest’s Favorite Flavor

Blue Moon ice cream is a beloved flavor that has been a Midwest staple for decades. It’s a mystery flavor that is known for its bright blue color and unique taste. While there are many theories about what exactly the ice cream tastes like, no one can seem to agree on one definitive answer.

Some people describe it as having hints of citrus, while others say that it tastes like Froot Loops or Fruity Pebbles cereal. There are even some who say that it tastes like cotton candy or bubble gum. Despite the mystery surrounding its flavor, it has remained a popular choice for ice cream lovers of all ages.

Whether you’re a longtime fan or have never tried it before, Blue Moon is definitely worth a taste. Its vibrant blue color and unique flavor make it fun and exciting to try. So, the next time you’re in Michigan or come across Blue Moon in your local ice cream shop, try it and join the debate about its flavor.


What Is Blue Moon Ice Cream?

Blue Moon is a unique and beloved ice cream flavor that is native to the Midwestern United States. It is known for its striking blue color and an elusive flavor that has been described in a variety of ways.

One thing that is for sure, though, is that this ice cream is a childhood favorite for many Midwesterners. It is a staple at local ice cream parlors and is often associated with warm summer days and carefree childhood memories. Even those who have never tried it are often drawn to its vibrant blue color and the sense of nostalgia that it evokes.

At the end of the day, the mystery surrounding Blue Moon only adds to its allure. Whether you love it or hate it, there is no denying that it is a beloved part of Midwestern culture and a testament to the power of food bringing people together.

History of Blue Moon Ice Cream

Blue Moon has been a beloved treat in the Upper Midwest of the United States for generations. However, its origin is shrouded in mystery, and there are many theories about how this unique flavor came to be.

Some people say that it was first created in Milwaukee Wisconsin, while others believe that it was invented in Ludington Michigan. Others claim that it was first made by an ice cream shop in South Dakota, or even that it was brought to the Midwest by German immigrants.

Regardless of its origin, Blue Moon quickly became a popular flavor in the region, and it remains a favorite today. Its bright blue color and sweet, fruity taste make it a fun and refreshing treat.


Ingredients of Blue Moon Ice Cream

At its core, Blue Moon is a mystery flavor, so its ingredients are a closely guarded secret. Plus, the ingredients can vary depending on the recipe and the brand. However, there are some clues as to what might be in this unique ice cream.

Some people say that it’s made with almond extract, while others believe that it contains raspberry or lemon flavoring. There are even some who claim that it’s simply a mixture of vanilla, lemon, and raspberry flavors.

Homemade Ice Cream Ingredients

However, some common ingredients are typically used to create this unique flavor in homemade ice cream recipes. One of the key ingredients is raspberry flavoring. This gives the ice cream its fruity taste and creates the signature blue color.

Lemon extract is also often used to enhance the flavor and add a tangy twist. In addition to the flavorings, this ice cream typically includes heavy whipping cream, whole milk, and sugar. This combination of ingredients creates a rich and creamy base for the ice cream.

To achieve the vibrant blue color, blue gel food coloring is often added to the mixture. While some recipes call for natural food coloring options — such as butterfly pea flower or spirulina — many commercial brands still use artificial coloring.

Other common ingredients found in homemade Blue Moon recipes may include vanilla extract, salt, and corn syrup. Overall, the combination of these ingredients creates a unique and delicious flavor that is loved by many ice cream enthusiasts.

A Flavor for Generations to Enjoy

Whether you prefer to make it at home or enjoy it at your favorite ice cream shop, understanding the key ingredients can help you appreciate Blue Moon even more. And despite the many theories about the ingredients, it’s a beloved part of Midwestern culture and will continue to be enjoyed for generations.


Popular Brands of Blue Moon Ice Cream

When it comes to Blue Moon, a few popular brands come to mind. Each of these brands offers a unique take on this classic flavor with fruity and vanilla notes that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. Here are some of the most well-known and beloved brands.

Perry’s Ice Cream

This New York-based company has been making ice cream since 1918 and is known for its Blue Moon flavor, which has been a fan favorite for generations. It has a fruity, vanilla flavor with a bright blue color that is sure to catch your eye.

Hudsonville Ice Cream

This Michigan-based company has been making ice cream since 1926 and is known for its high-quality ingredients and delicious flavors. Hudsonville’s Blue Moon is a popular choice and has a unique flavor that combines fruity and vanilla notes.

Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream

This Wisconsin-based company has been making ice cream since 1962 and is known for its unique flavors and high-quality ingredients. Chocolate Shoppe’s Blue Moon has a fruity, vanilla flavor and a bright blue color that is sure to stand out.


This Minnesota-based company has been making ice cream since 1914 and is known for its wide range of flavors and quality ingredients. Kemps’ Blue Moon has a fruity, vanilla flavor and a bright blue color that is sure to catch your eye.


Variations of Blue Moon Ice Cream

We’ve already established that the flavor of Blue Moon is a mystery. But did you know that there are also variations of this beloved Midwest treat? Here are a few variations that you might encounter:

  • Smurf Ice Cream: This variation includes miniature marshmallows mixed into the ice cream. The marshmallows give it a chewy texture and make it resemble the blue cartoon characters from the popular 80s TV show.
  • Fruity Pebbles: Some ice cream shops add Fruity Pebbles cereal to the ice cream to give it a fruity twist. The cereal adds a crunchy texture and a burst of fruity flavor.
  • Blue Raspberry: This variation is made by adding blue raspberry flavoring to the ice cream base. The result is a bright blue ice cream with a sweet and tangy flavor.
  • Lemon: Some people claim that the original Blue Moon flavor is supposed to taste like lemon. To create this variation, lemon flavor is added to the base to give it a tart and refreshing taste.
  • Almond: Another popular variation is almond flavored. The almond flavor gives the ice cream a nutty taste and pairs well with the blue coloring.

No matter which variation you try, one thing is for sure — This is a unique and delicious treat that you won’t find anywhere else.

FAQs About Blue Moon Ice Cream

What is the history of Blue Moon ice cream?

The origins of Blue Moon are unclear, but it’s believed to have originated in the Midwest in the 1930s or 1940s. It quickly became a regional favorite and has remained popular ever since.

What are the ingredients in Blue Moon ice cream?

Blue Moon is a mysterious flavor that has been around for decades, but its exact ingredients are still a closely guarded secret. Some say it tastes like Froot Loops, while others taste hints of raspberry, lemon, or almond.

Most recipes for homemade Blue Moon include heavy cream, whole milk, sugar, vanilla extract, and raspberry and lemon flavors. However, the exact ingredients and ratios used by commercial ice cream makers remain a mystery.

What makes Blue Moon ice cream blue?

Another mystery of Blue Moon is its bright blue color. Some say it’s simply food coloring, while others speculate that it’s a combination of natural and artificial colorings. The exact reason remains unknown.

Where can I find Blue Moon ice cream?

Blue Moon is most commonly found in the Midwest, especially in Michigan, Wisconsin, and Illinois. However, it can also be found in some ice cream shops and grocery stores in other parts of the country.

If you’re having trouble finding it, try searching for specialty ice cream shops or ordering it online.

Is Blue Moon ice cream gluten-free?

It depends on the brand and recipe. Some brands of Blue Moon may contain gluten, especially if they use ingredients like cake batter or cookie dough.

However, many brands and homemade recipes are gluten-free. If you have celiac disease or gluten intolerance, check the nutrition facts or ask the ice cream shop before indulging.

What other flavors pair well with Blue Moon ice cream?

Blue Moon is a unique flavor that can be paired with a variety of other flavors. Some popular options include Superman ice cream (a mix of blue, red, and yellow ice cream), raspberry, and chocolate chip.

Grab a Bowl or Cone of Blue Moon Ice Cream Today

If you aren’t familiar with Blue Moon ice cream, it’s always the perfect time to try a scoop — or three! Then, tell us in the comments what flavors you taste.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *